There’s a bit of symmetry to the players on stage for The Flying Lovers of Vitebsk, as they enter in pairs of two.
First, we’re introduced to the two musicians—Katrina Michaels and Jeremy Crawford—who walk down the stairs of the house singing a Yiddish tune. They break the fourth wall to welcome the audience (and of course remind us to turn off our cell phones,) before spending most of the performance confined to the corner of the stage. But this is a misleading sentence, given the soundtrack they provide (including vocals and many instruments) and an occasional acting assist when a supporting character is needed. (My favorite is Michaels playing Bella’s mother, who expresses her emotions through accordion pulls. :P)
Then there’s the actors—Jamie Smithson as the famous 20th century painter, Marc Chagall, and Dani Stoller as his wife and often muse, Bella. In broad strokes, the play covers their love affair (a dramaturgy timeline is also included in the playbill.) They meet in their hometown of Vitebsk, fall madly in love, and struggle to hold it together while the world around them changes, particularly with the Russian Revolution.
Chagall’s paintings of the lovers in flight serve as the cornerstone for the play, but how to portray them on stage? With the introduction of the final two players—aerialists Thomas Martin and Rachael Small. The final curtain on the stage pulls back to reveal them on a rectangular aerial hoop. They come in and out to contribute to the most emotional moments, bringing this trifecta to its ultimate peak.
Perhaps it’s unfair to say that six performers across three art types are all that comprise the play. In another amusing, fourth-wall moment, Smithson as Chagall at one point criticizes actors. Historically, this was during the time that the artist was painting for the Moscow State Yiddish Theater. To paraphrase the line: “I wish the actors would stop moving, so people could admire the scenery!” 😛
In this play, “the scenery” was largely made up of Chagall’s paintings, which were carefully projected onto a variety of backdrops, brought to life by several other designers. Yes, it really is unfair to not include this art type in a play that is, after all, predominately about a painter.
But for me and my biases (speaking of the EDCJCC, my choir just started rehearsing there again for the Chanukah season!) I was most taken with the music. Although this play was first performed a decade ago in Bristol, England, the Theater J version includes entirely new compositions by Sarah O’Halloran. The original Ian Ross music is also present, alongside Yiddish folksongs and a revolutionary number or two, all adding to the complicated reality of the Chagalls and other Russian Jews of the time.
Marc and Bella escaped the Holocaust by fleeing to New York. But unfortunately, due to penicillin shortages, Bella died at 54 after contracting strep throat. One of the final images of the play features Stoller, now on the aerial hoop, flying away from Chagall, in a rendition of his painting “The Promenade.”
Throughout October, Theater J and the EDCJCC are offering special programming about the play and about Chagall’s legacy more broadly. For a final art form—writing—I left the theater intrigued to learn more about Bella Rosenfeld Chagall, who published memoirs about her life and a vanished Jewish history. Vitebsk was largely destroyed by the Nazis in 1944. They rounded up and murdered the Jews of the Vitebsk ghetto in 1941.
Once again, it all comes back to art—so many types of art—keeping places and history, and also the intimate love between two people, alive. “Marc and Bella were confronted with a whirlwind of events that set the world they knew spinning,” Director Hayley Finn wrote in the playbill. “Though not always easy, they remained anchored to each other, and that deep connection inspired them both artistically…Together, they not only created a life filled with art, but saw the world through a lens that connects art with love and unlocks the possibility of imagination.”
The Flying Lovers of Vitebsk was written by Daniel Jamieson, and Hayley Finn directed the DC premiere. Gwynne Flannagan Cox was choreographer and aerial consultant. It’s opening Theater J’s ’26-’27 season, and will be on stage through November 1.
For more of my theater coverage, check out my “Books, Plays, Movies and Music” tab.











